Should I Get an Acrylic or Tile Shower in My Bathroom Remodel?

It’s the big bathroom question: acrylic or tile? If you’re planning a Tampa bathroom remodel, this decision is more than just looks. It shapes how your bathroom feels, how it functions, and how easy it is to live with day-to-day. And here’s the truth—there’s no universal “right” answer. The right choice is the one that works for you. This guide can help you decide:

Acrylic Showers: Seamless and Low-Maintenance

Want simple maintenance and quick results? Acrylic showers are smooth, seamless, and easy to keep clean. Installation is fast, which means less disruption to your daily life. And cost-wise, they’re generally friendlier to the budget than tile.

They’re an especially smart choice for guest bathrooms or secondary baths—spaces where practicality matters most. If you want something that looks neat, functions reliably, and doesn’t ask much of you in return, acrylic is the way to go. But acrylic has its limits. Customization is minimal—your color and pattern options aren’t as extensive as tile. And while they’re durable, they don’t quite have the long-term luxury feel of stone or tile.

Learn More: Is Getting Only a Guest Bathroom Remodeled Worth It?

Tile Showers: Custom, Classic, and Packed with Personality

Tile is the choice for homeowners who want their bathroom to feel like a personal retreat. It’s not just about durability—it’s about design freedom. From timeless subway patterns to bold mosaics, tile lets you create a look that’s entirely your own.

This option works great inmaster bathrooms and spa-inspired spaces, really anywhere you want the design to feel elevated and tailored to your taste. Tile requires more care and investment up front, but the payoff is a bathroom that looks and feels one-of-a-kind.

Learn More: Shower Wall Panels vs Tiles: Which Is Best for My Bathroom Remodel?

Which Option Is Right for Your Tampa Bathroom Renovation?

This is where your goals and style come into play.

If you need quick installation and easy maintenance, acrylic is your pick.
If you’re after design impact, personalization, and long-term luxury, tile is a better investment.
If you’re somewhere in between? We’ll help you explore hybrid options, like tile accent walls with an acrylic base.

Don’t go for what’s trendy—we’ll help you determine what feels right when you step into that space every morning.

Permits and Peace of Mind

One thing homeowners sometimes overlook: all remodeling projects require a permit. At Revive Design and Renovation, we handle that for you—every time—so your remodel is stress-free, code-compliant, and done right.

Want a Shower Designed Just for You? Reach Out Today!

An acrylic shower can be practical, and a tile shower can be stunning. But, honestly, the best remodel is the one that feels effortless because it was focused on your lifestyle. That’s what we do at Revive Design and Renovation. We make the process focused on you—your needs and your total comfort. Ready to choose the shower that’s right for you? Call us today at (813) 680-4103 and let’s design it together!